Concerns Over Edinburgh Council’s STL Policies: A Call for Fairness
A letter has been sent to the City of Edinburgh Council (CEC) raising significant concerns over the implementation of Short-Term Let (STL) licensing policies, highlighting issues of maladministration, unjust enforcement actions, and threats to public safety.
The letter underscores the Council’s continued demand for planning permission or a certificate of lawfulness, despite a Court of Session ruling stating that such requirements are not mandatory for businesses operating before 5 September 2022. This has led to self-catering operators incurring unnecessary fees, with projected costs to the Council exceeding £300,000, potentially rising to over £1 million should further complaints be upheld.
Additionally, concerns have been raised about enforcement actions against legitimate operators, including a case referred to the Procurator Fiscal, potentially unlawfully. The policies adopted by the Council amount to a de facto ban on STL operations, described by Lord Braid as “oppressive and disproportionate,” and may violate human rights laws protecting property rights.
Further alarm has been raised over the Council’s decision to waive essential health and safety checks for Temporary Exemptions during the Festival period. This creates a two-tier system where visitor safety is compromised, places the Council at risk of liability, and may encourage unregulated STLs.
The letter calls for a fair and sustainable approach, urging the Council to engage with industry representatives to develop balanced policies that uphold safety while supporting Edinburgh’s economy and cultural reputation.
You can read a copy of the letter here.